FOIA News: Pennsylvania treasure hunters sue the DOJ in Civil War gold case

Pennsylvania treasure hunters sue the DOJ in Civil War gold case

By Jason Nark, The Philadelphia Inquirer, Jan. 4, 2022

The Pennsylvania treasure hunters on a never-ending quest to find a legendary lost shipment of Civil War gold are suing the Feds for documents.

In a lawsuit filed Tuesday in U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C., Dennis Parada, a longtime treasure hunter from Clearfield County, alleges that the FBI has failed to provide him with any records of the case of the Elk County gold, despite a FOIA request filed more than three years ago

Read more here.

FOIA News: Transportation's request backlog climbed 13% in FY 2021

The U.S. Department of Transportation’s FOIA request backlog increased in fiscal year 2021 by 569 requests, or 13.3 percent, according to quarterly FOIA data posted on DOT’s website. At the end of FY 2020, DOT’s request backlog stood at 4272 requests; it climbed to 4841 request by the end of the fourth quarter of fiscal year 2021. DOT received 15729 requests in FY 2021, a 7.5%,increase from FY 2020, when it received 14632 requests. The number of requests processed by DOT dropped from 15433 in FY 2020 to 14700 in FY 2021, a decrease of 5 percent,

FOIA News: USDA to proactively post slaughter plant records

USDA to Proactively Post Slaughter Records to Settle Lawsuit by AWI, Farm Sanctuary

Press Release, Animal Welfare Inst., Jan. 4, 2021

In a huge win for transparency and accountability, the US Department of Agriculture has agreed to publicly disclose on its website records related to the treatment of animals in US slaughter plants to settle a lawsuit filed by the Animal Welfare Institute (AWI) and Farm Sanctuary. Marian Payson, a federal magistrate judge for the US District Court for the Western District of New York, approved the settlement yesterday.

The 2018 complaint alleged that the USDA failed to proactively disclose records relating to the enforcement of two laws—the Humane Methods of Slaughter Act and the Poultry Products Inspection Act—as required by the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA).

Read more here.

FOIA News: SCOTUS to consider "consultant corollary" petition

On Friday, January 7, 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court will consider whether to grant a petition for a writ of certiorari to the Fifth Circuit case Jobe v. NTSB,. The petition asks the Court to reject the “consultant corollary” doctrine outright or, alternatively, to hold that a “self-interested party helping an agency to investigate its own conduct cannot possibly create “intra-agency” communications.” The docket material is available on SCOTUSblog here.

Court opinion issued Dec. 30, 2021

Akel v. DOJ (D.D.C.) -- concluding that the Executive Office of U.S. Attorneys performed reasonable search for records concerning plaintiff’s prosecution, except for its failure to try to recover and search emails of one former prosecutor who worked on plaintiff’s case.

Summaries of all published opinions issued since April 2015 are available here.

FOIA News: Backlog of requests worsened at DOD, DOE, HHS, DOJ, and State in FY 2021; improved at Education; steady at Interior

Backlogged FOIA requests increased by double digits in fiscal year 2021 at the Department of Defense; Energy; Health & Human Services; Justice; and State, according to quarterly data available on FOIA.gov. The Department of Education, by contrast, was able to reduce its backlog by double digits, while Interior’s backlog increased by only single digits. Here is a breakdown of the preliminary data:

• Defense: 11% increase, from 16,000 backlogged requests in 2020 to 17,774 in 2021.

• Education: 19% decrease, from 819 backlogged requests in 2020 to 693 in 2021.

• Energy: 22.7% increase, from 554 backlogged requests in 2020 to 680 in 2021.

• HHS: 14% increase, from 8817 backlogged requests in 2020 to 10,053 in 2021

• Interior: 4% increase, from 4100 backlogged requests in 2020 to 4267 in 2021.

• DOJ: 38% increase, from 36,018 backlogged requests in 2020 to 50,017 in 2021.

• State: 15.8% increase, from 13,798 backlogged requests in 2020 to 15,984 in 2021.

Other cabinets agencies have not yet entered data in FOIA.gov for all four quarters of FY 2021. Agencies were required to provide their FY 2021 annual reports to DOJ’s Office of Information Policy for review by November 15, 2021, and they must post their annual reports online by March 1, 2021.

Court opinions issued Dec. 28, 2021

Kalbers v. DOJ (9th Cir.) -- reversing district court’s decision that Volkswagen AG could not intervene as of right in FOIA lawsuit involving the company’s records and holding, in most relevant part, that the factor of delay “is measured from the date the proposed intervenor knew or should have known the parties would no longer adequately protect its interests” as opposed to the date when proposed intervenor learned of the FOIA lawsuit.

Kinnucan v. Nat'l Sec. Agency (W.D. Wash.) -- deciding that: (1) House Appropriations Committee report concerning 1967 attack on U.S. naval intelligence ship was not an “agency record” subject to FOIA, because “the Committee clearly indicated its intent to control the report by marking it ’Not for release unless and until authorized by the Committee’”; (2) CIA failed to carry its burden with respect to its withholdings under Exemptions 1 and 3, necessitating in camera review; and (3) despite age of records, CIA could retain its Exemption 6 withholdings because plaintiff failed to articulate any public interest in disclosure.

Summaries of all published opinions issued since April 2015 are available here.

Court opinion issued Dec. 23, 2021

Property of the People v. DOJ (D.D.C.) -- on renewed summary judgment, concluding that the FBI properly relied on Exemption 7(C) in refusing to confirm or deny existence of investigatory records pertaining to former congressperson, Dana Rohrabacher of California.

Summaries of all published opinions issued since April 2015 are available here.

Court opinions issued Dec. 21, 2021

Hammond v. DOD (D.D.C.) -- finding that: (1) Walter Reed National Military Medical Center performed “reasonable and adequate” searches in response to plaintiff’s multiple requests, noting that plaintiff was not “entitled to a search of his own choosing”; (2) agency properly invoked Exemption 6 to withhold names of individuals who requested their own medical records; (3) plaintiff was not entitled to injunctive relief based on agency’s use of batched FOIA tracking numbers.

Cole v. Copan (D.D.C.) -- adopting in part and denying in part magistrate’s recommendations and holding that: (1) FEMA and NIST did not adequately explain how it searched for requested records concerning the collapse of the World Trade Center buildings on September 11, 2001; (2) plaintiff was entitled to limited discovery from FEMA concerning 490,000 pages of WTC-related records stored at NARA, but that FEMA sufficiently explained discrepancy as to whether certain missing records might be in its regional office’s local archives.

Summaries of all published opinions issued since April 2015 are available here.

FOIA News: FERC wins Exemption 6 case at D.C. Circuit

DC Circ. Sides With FERC Over Nonprofit's FOIA Suit

By Clark Mindock, Law360, Dec. 20, 2021

The D. C. Circuit has said the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission need not provide more than the initials and street names of property owners potentially impacted by a now-discontinued pipeline project, rejecting a nonprofit's claims that full names were necessary. A three-judge panel said Friday that the Niskanen Center had failed to identify an overriding public interest that would compel the federal agency to disclose the full names and addresses of landowners who own property along the pipeline's path since the nonprofit would've been able to figure out those contacts from the offered information. While the Niskanen Center had argued the Freedom. . .

Read more here (accessible with free 7-day trial)

Copy of decision here.