ICE May Be Breaking the Law to Stonewall Reporters
By Dave Levinthal, Columbia Journalism Review, Sept. 22, 2025
Since late December, J. Dale Shoemaker, a reporter for the Investigative Post, a nonprofit newsroom based in Buffalo, has filed seventeen Freedom of Information Act requests with the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement and US Customs and Border Protection to guide his deep dives into federal law enforcement activity, deportation actions, and ICE detention centers in upstate New York. In return, he says, he has gotten only documents that were redacted beyond comprehension, or nothing at all. “I have not received a satisfactory response to a single one of them,” Shoemaker said.
Ryanne Mena, of the Los Angeles Daily News, sent ICE a FOIA request on January 24 for all grievance forms filed by detainees at facilities in Adelanto, California, between 2016 and early 2025. Nearly eight months later, she said, she’s received nothing: ICE “has failed to provide me with an estimated date of production despite repeated requests.”
Read more here.
FOIA follies: How the deep state avoids transparency
By Mike Chamberlain, Washington Examiner, Sept. 22, 2025
* * *
But to make FOIA requests with any frequency is to encounter a variety of glitches, delays, misunderstandings, frustrating redactions, and more. Sometimes, these incidents are simple mishaps. Other times, they look like intentional stalls and mistakes to slow the process in the hope that the requester gets discouraged and goes away.
And many do go away because when a federal agency is uncooperative with FOIA requests, the ultimate recourse is to sue. For organizations like mine, Protect the Public’s Trust, that’s part of what we do. We are built to pursue information into court. For most news organizations whose entire legal budget is reserved for libel, plagiarism, and copyright infringement (let alone for private citizens without legal budgets), the legal costs are prohibitive.
Read more here.