FOIA Advisor

FOIA News: 9th Circuit overturns dismissal based on identity of requester

FOIA News (2015-2023)Ryan MulveyComment

Appeals Court Rolls Its Eyes At Government's Attempt To Dodge FOIA Litigation By Pretending It Didn't Know Who Was Seeking Documents

Tim Cushing, Tech Dirt, June 4, 2018

Government agencies, for the most part, treat public records requesters as weeds in the garden of governance: a pest that can never be fully eradicated, but rather tolerated with as much annoyance as possible. Whatever can't be made to disappear with hefty fee demands or months of stonewalling will be given as little attention and compliance as possible. This attitude has turned FOIA requesters into frequent litigators seeking to hold one branch of the government accountable by using another.

When Cheryl Brantley, a member of activist group A Better Way for BPA, requested records from the Bonneville Power Administration (run by the Department of Energy), she filled out the agency's online FOIA form and waited. And waited. And waited some more before finally suing.

BPA responded by declaring A Better Way had no standing to file a lawsuit. It decided to get hypertechnical about Brantley's FOIA submission, claiming no one but Brantley herself should be allowed to sue.

Read more here.